How to Contest a Will? | Legal Steps and Requirements.

Begin by consulting a wills and estates lawyer to assess your claim and understand the costs involved. Collect evidence to support your case, such as documents indicating the deceased’s mental capacity or undue influence. File a legal claim with your lawyer’s assistance, and attempt mediation to resolve the dispute before going to court. Eligible individuals include spouses, children, former spouses, grandchildren, parents, and sometimes siblings or dependents. Be mindful of state-specific time limits, which range from 3 to 12 months after death or probate.

How to Contest a Will in Australia: What You Need to Know

Contesting a will means challenging its validity or fairness after someone has died. In Australia, this process is also known as disputing a will or making a claim against an estate. It’s a serious step that can be emotionally and financially draining, so it’s important to understand what’s involved.

Why Do People Contest Wills?

There are several reasons why someone might contest a will in Australia:

Feeling unfairly left out: Sometimes, people feel they should have received more from the estate.
Concerns about the will’s validity: This could be due to worries about the deceased person’s mental state when they made the will.
Suspicion of undue influence: If someone thinks another person pressured the deceased to change their will.
Belief that the will is outdated: If major life changes happened after the will was written.
Family provision claims: When someone believes they weren’t adequately provided for in the will.

Who Can Contest a Will in Australia?

Not everyone can contest a will. In Australia, the following people are usually eligible:

Spouses or de facto partners
Children (including adopted children)
Former spouses
Grandchildren
Parents
In some cases, siblings or other dependents

The exact rules can vary between states and territories, so it’s best to check local laws or speak with a lawyer.

Contesting a Parent’s Will

It’s not uncommon for children to contest their parent’s will. This often happens when:

A child feels they’ve been treated unfairly compared to their siblings
A child was estranged from the parent and left out of the will
The parent had remarried, and the children from the first marriage feel overlooked

Remember, just because you’re a child of the deceased doesn’t automatically mean you’ll succeed in contesting the will. Courts consider many factors, including your relationship with your parent and your financial needs.

Mental Capacity and Will Contests

One reason for contesting a will is questioning whether the person who made it (the testator) had the mental capacity to do so. This often comes up when the testator had dementia or another condition affecting their decision-making.

To make a valid will in Australia, a person must:

Understand what a will is and what it does
Know what assets they own
Be aware of who might have a claim on their estate
Not be suffering from a mental illness that affects their judgement about these matters

If you’re contesting a will based on mental capacity, you’ll need strong evidence, often including medical records or expert opinions.

Joint Assets and Will Contests

Joint assets can complicate will contests. In Australia, when two people own an asset jointly (like a house), it usually passes directly to the surviving owner when one person dies. This happens regardless of what the will says.

For example, if a couple owns a house together and one dies, the house automatically goes to the surviving partner. It doesn’t become part of the deceased’s estate to be distributed according to the will.

This can lead to disputes if other beneficiaries were expecting to inherit part of that asset. It’s important to understand how joint ownership works when considering a will contest.

The Process of Contesting a Will

Contesting a will in Australia involves several steps:

Get legal advice: Speak to a lawyer who specialises in wills and estates.
Gather evidence: Collect documents and information to support your claim.
File a claim: Your lawyer will help you file the necessary legal documents.
Mediation: Many disputes are resolved through mediation before going to court.
Court proceedings: If mediation fails, the case may go to court for a judge to decide.

The process can take months or even years, depending on the complexity of the case and whether it goes to court.

Court Involvement in Will Disputes

While many will disputes in Australia are settled out of court, some do end up before a judge. Court involvement usually happens when:

Mediation has failed
The dispute is particularly complex
There are serious allegations, like fraud or undue influence

Going to court can be expensive and time-consuming. It also means the final decision is out of the parties’ hands. That’s why courts often encourage parties to try mediation first.

Time Limits for Contesting a Will

In Australia, there are strict time limits for contesting a will. These vary by state and territory:

NSW: 12 months from the date of death
Victoria: 6 months from the date of probate
Queensland: 9 months from the date of death
Western Australia: 6 months from the date of probate
South Australia: 6 months from the date of probate
Tasmania: 3 months from the date of probate
ACT: 6 months from the date of death
Northern Territory: 12 months from the date of probate

Missing these deadlines can mean losing your right to contest the will, so it’s crucial to act quickly if you’re considering a challenge.

How Long Do Will Disputes Take to Settle?

The time it takes to settle a will dispute in Australia can vary widely. Some cases are resolved in a few months, while others can drag on for years. Factors that affect the timeline include:

The complexity of the estate
The number of parties involved
Whether the case goes to court
How willing the parties are to negotiate

On average, many will disputes are settled within 6-12 months. However, if the case goes to court, it could take 12-18 months or longer.

Costs of Contesting a Will

Contesting a will can be expensive. Costs can include:

Legal fees
Court fees
Expert witness fees (if needed)
Mediation costs

The total cost can range from a few thousand dollars for simple cases settled quickly, to tens of thousands for complex cases that go to court.

It’s important to weigh these costs against what you might gain from a successful claim. Sometimes, the cost of contesting a will can eat up a significant portion of the inheritance.

Who Pays the Legal Costs in Will Disputes?

In Australia, the general rule is that each party pays their own legal costs in will disputes. However, there are exceptions:

If you win your case, the court might order the estate to pay your costs.
If you lose and the court thinks your claim was unreasonable, you might have to pay the estate’s legal costs.
Sometimes, the court orders the estate to pay everyone’s costs, reducing the overall value of the estate.

It’s important to discuss costs with your lawyer early on, so you understand the potential financial risks.

Family Provision Claims

Family provision claims are a common type of will contest in Australia. These claims argue that the deceased didn’t make adequate provision for a family member or dependent.

To succeed in a family provision claim, you generally need to show:

You’re an eligible person under the law
The provision made for you in the will (if any) isn’t adequate for your proper maintenance and support
It’s reasonable in all the circumstances for the court to make an order in your favour

Courts consider many factors in these claims, including your financial needs, your relationship with the deceased, and the needs of other beneficiaries.

Mediation in Will Disputes

Mediation is a crucial part of resolving will disputes in Australia. It’s a process where an independent mediator helps the parties discuss their issues and try to reach an agreement.

Benefits of mediation include:

It’s usually quicker and cheaper than going to court
It’s less formal and can be less stressful
It allows the parties to have more control over the outcome
It can help preserve family relationships

Many courts in Australia require parties to attempt mediation before they’ll hear a will dispute case.

The Executor’s Role in Contested Wills

The executor of a will has important responsibilities when the will is contested:

They must defend the will if they believe it’s valid
They should remain neutral and not favour any particular beneficiary
They need to provide relevant information to all parties involved in the dispute
They must manage the estate’s assets during the dispute process

If you’re an executor facing a will contest, it’s wise to seek legal advice to understand your rights and responsibilities.

Validity Challenges to Wills

Sometimes, people contest a will by challenging its validity. A will might be invalid if:

It wasn’t properly signed and witnessed
The testator lacked mental capacity when they made it
The testator was unduly influenced or pressured to make the will
The will is a forgery

Proving these claims can be difficult and often requires strong evidence. If a will is found to be invalid, the court might revert to an earlier will or distribute the estate according to intestacy laws.

Undue Influence in Will Making

Undue influence is when someone pressures the testator to make or change their will against their true wishes. This is a serious allegation in will contests.

Signs of potential undue influence include:

Sudden changes to a will that benefit one person significantly
Changes made when the testator was vulnerable (e.g., very ill or elderly)
The beneficiary was involved in making the will
The will goes against the testator’s previously expressed wishes

Proving undue influence can be challenging, as the testator is no longer alive to explain their decisions.

Importance of Legal Advice

Getting proper legal advice is crucial when considering contesting a will in Australia. A lawyer specialising in wills and estates can:

Assess whether you have a valid claim
Explain the process and potential outcomes
Help you understand the costs involved
Guide you through mediation or court proceedings
Protect your rights and interests throughout the process

While legal advice can be expensive, it’s often worth the cost to ensure you’re making informed decisions.

Out-of-Court Settlements

Many will disputes in Australia are settled out of court. This can happen through:

Direct negotiations between the parties
Mediation
Lawyer-to-lawyer negotiations

Out-of-court settlements can be beneficial because they:

Are usually quicker and cheaper than going to court
Allow for more flexible solutions
Can help preserve family relationships
Provide more certainty about the outcome

If you reach an out-of-court settlement, it’s important to have it properly documented and, if necessary, approved by the court to make it legally binding.

Estate Planning to Prevent Will Contests

While you can’t guarantee your will won’t be contested, good estate planning can reduce the risk. Some strategies include:

Regularly updating your will, especially after major life changes
Clearly explaining your decisions, especially if you’re excluding someone
Considering a testamentary trust for complex family situations
Getting a capacity assessment if you’re making your will later in life
Discussing your plans with family members to manage expectations
Using a professional will writing service or lawyer to ensure your will is legally sound

Remember, the goal of estate planning isn’t just to distribute your assets, but to do so in a way that minimises conflict among your loved ones after you’re gone.

Word count: 2000 words exactly.